I thought my love affair with the hot hatch ended when my twenties arrived, when girlfriends stopped being overnight conveniences and when – as happens with all men at some point – the size of my car began to be more important than the size of my manhood.
The VW Golf GTi 16v was the hot-hatch of choice when I hung out with girls form Essex who left their cheese-string thongs under the passenger seat for my mother to find and then, in my twenties and when my career began to be more a priority rather than a nuisance, it was the BMW 3-series that was the car of choice, because it was the one that was most likely to get you in to the knickers of the slender young female sales executive who wore the pinstripe trouser suit and smoked Marlboro Ultra Lights. When I got married and settled down to create a family, it was the urban four-by-four that became the motor to have, so that I could blend in with the Yummy Mummies on the school run.
From here on in my motoring future looks bleak. As I get older, greyer and fatter, I’ll have to start looking at the Mercedes S-Class or the BMW 7-series to meet my more stately position in society and to allow me to cavort with attractive middle-aged ladies who dress demurely, sip champagne and discreetly shave their bikini lines in the hopes that it will delay the onset of menopause.
In my mid-thirties, then, with wife and two children, the idea of the hot hatch is nothing more than a fond, but distant, memory. Or so I thought, until somebody handed me the keys to a 2007 VW Polo GTi.
For all intents and purposes, the Polo GTi – as superminis go – is quite innocuous. You wouldn’t really realise that the car sitting behind you, with the spotty oik behind the wheel desperately flashing his headlights to move you out of the way, had about 150bhp to play with, for example. You also wouldn’t realise that it can do the 0-60 dash in 8.2 seconds or wind itself up to an acne-popping 134mph. And because of this, you probably wouldn’t care that its sports suspension means it’s quite nifty round the corners, too.
You wouldn’t realise any of this because, well, it’s quite bland to look at. Sure, it’s got slightly flared wheel arches and a bespoke honeycomb grill to give it a beefier appearance, but if it didn’t say GTi on the front (or the back) you’d be none the wiser.
If you were looking for a hot hatch, you probably wouldn’t even think of buying a VW these days. The original hot-hatch was the Golf GTi, available in 8 or 16 valve format, but that was the modern day Polo’s great great great grandfather twice removed and these days the Golf is all frumpy and fat. Today’s hot-hatches are made by Renault and Ford, Suzuki or Vauxhall and you’d be forgiven, if you are young enough to still get away with looking cool behind the wheel of such a car, for choosing the Renault SportClio or the Ford Fiesta ST over the Polo. Both look far more exciting than the Polo GTi and are a little bit more exciting to drive. The Clio, for example, is almost a second and a half quicker in the 0-60 dash than the Polo while the Fiesta ST is almost £2’000 cheaper and, despite those rather garish go-faster lines, manages to be marginally faster too.
But there’s still something to be said for the spritely Polo that puts it over its rivals. The Fiesta is, well, a Ford while the Renault’s switchgear has a touch of Fisher Price about them. In contrast, the Polo is a lot better built – as you’d expect from German designers who appear to be deliberately bred with a touch of OCD in their systems – and you drive the car with a confidence that everything will work when you want it to. Compared to the Renault and the Ford, the Polo’s blue light dashboard and contrasting red switch gear looks funky and futuristic.
And then there’s the level of specification. The Polo is literally littered with useful, functional gadgets. Automatic Air Conditioning, for a start, and electric windows all round (if you get the five-door version). Neither the Renault or the Ford boast these as standard. The Polo also sports an indicator light to tell you when your tyres might have gone flat, and a stereo system with eight-speakers that’s perfect for listening to music made by a man who owns his own dungeon.
Of course, when you drive it VW’s heritage shows through. The little Polo simply whizzes around B-roads as if it were made for the challenge, despite having only 16-inch alloy wheels as standard compared to the Renault and Ford’s 17. Its 1.8 litre turbocharged engine is eager and exciting, although it can get a little asthmatic towards the top of the rev range as the turbo starts to run out of puff, but it’s brisk and inviting and the standard fit ESP (Electronic Stability Programme) includes EDL (Electronic Differential Lock) coupled with the ASR (which is nothing more exciting than Traction Control) and ABS make this car as difficult to crash as it is to understand all the acronyms associated with it.
The chunky steering wheel, aluminium drilled pedals and overall superb quality of this car make it a little joy to drive. In fact, as hot hatches go, it can only be surpassed by another German hot hatch. The Mini.
The Mini Cooper is slower than the Polo GTi while the Cooper S is undoubtedly quicker. The trouble is that the Cooper might start out cheaper than the Polo, but by the time you’ve added the options you want on it to bring the spec level to match the Polo’s it becomes more expensive. And it’s not as big – you can barely fit a couple of kids in the back, let alone a child seat or two, whilst the Polo is better designed for the Yummy Mummy than her VW Touareg is. And the Cooper S starts at £16’000 only to end up at £18’000 by the time you’ve added alloy wheels and air conditioning. In fact, there’s almost 100 different options you can add to your Mini Cooper and the Cooper S, fully loaded, will set you back almost the same as a good BMW 3-series, only it’s not as good as the 3-series and not as good looking as the Polo. That said, the Cooper S is blisteringly good fun to drive...
Still, if you’re young enough to still be in love with the hot hatch, or are having a mid-life crisis and can’t afford a Porsche, the VW Polo GTi is a great choice to consider. It’s priced competitively at a little over £15’000 brand new, kitted out with enough equipment to keep the average joy-rider occupied, comfortable, spacious, safe and quick, is reasonably economical returning a shade under 40mpg on the combined cycle and, being German, it’s pretty much bomb-proof too.
With all that said, however, the hot-hatch is still not a car of choice for a man approaching middle-age. If I owned it, it would look like I was desperately trying to recapture my youth. The Yummy Mummies would sneer as it quivered alongside their Range Rover Sports and BMW X5s and Lady Toff would rather let her pubic hair grow back than be seen in the passenger seat beside me.
But it’s perfect for single lads in their late teens or early twenties who like to do handbrake turns around Tesco’s car park late at night with aftermarket neon lights glowing eerily alongside the exhaust pipe. Or for strange little men called Dave who live in Red Lodge...