I was a huge fan of Doctor Who as a child, spending many a Saturday afternoon watching from behind the sofa, a cushion or, when he wasn’t away working, my father’s hand, which I’d pull across my face every time a Cyberman or Dalek appeared on the screen.
I’ve often classed myself as a closet Trekkie, but I’ve never been afraid to admit I am something of a Whovian. After all, being a fan of Doctor Who isn’t quite as frowned upon as being a fan of Star Trek seems to be.
It’s also difficult to decide who I’d choose as my favourite Doctor. Many would argue Tom Baker; I was always quite a fan of Peter Davidson. Sylvester McCoy was quite bizarre, but even he and Colin Baker had their place in the regeneration game. We’ve all got a favourite, whether it’s the one who was most prominent when we were children, or the one that just happened to play a particular episode very well indeed. Some Doctors stand out more than others because of the companions they had.
Davidson stands out to me mainly because, by some quirk of Sci-Fi nature, I ended up with all the Target books of the episodes that contained him as the Doctor, including
Time-Flight, which – for some reason – I read repeatedly and is all about a Concorde flight that disappears. Great stuff.
But it has to be said that, twenty six years down the line from that episode, Doctor Who is still going great guns and David Tennant will take some beating. Certainly, it’s amusing to see my own two children cowering behind the sofa as they watch the programme, having spent half an hour beforehand desperately trying to convince me not to put it on.
And Doctor Who has always been about suspending some of your beliefs and just letting fantasy take over. Which is why I was extremely disappointed with the closing episodes of this last series, which took suspending belief to a whole new level.
All series, we’ve had to put up with Catherine Tate as the irksome Donna Noble, touted throughout the series as the most important companion the Doctor has ever had, yet – and I’m not exaggerating here – was possibly an even more annoying sidekick than
Tegan Jovanka. Tate’s acting ability stretched my beliefs a little too far and I spent most of the last series waiting for her to either blurt out “am I bovvered” or for David Tennant to punch her in the face.
Then we reached the penultimate episode for 2008 –
The Stolen Earth – where planet Earth was simply popped out of its spot in the Solar System, leaving everything in its geocentric orbit wondering just where the hell it had gone, and reappearing in another spot in space, surrounded by twenty six other planets, all circling a fairly big Dalek space station, the design of which seems to have borrowed rather heavily on George Lucas’s
Death Star.
Allowing for the fact that we’ll just have to believe the Daleks do, indeed, have the power to simply pull large planets instantaneously from anywhere they like in the universe, I have to say it did take a stretch of imagination to believe that very little structural damage seemed to have happened anywhere around the globe, nor did the sudden presence of twenty six other rather large planets seem to have any effect on the Earth’s gravitation pull, thus allowing humans to still walk around on the ground, and the lack of natural sunlight or the sudden change in atmospheric pressure didn’t seem to have any effect on the oxygen supply, meaning all us lucky humans didn’t start rolling around on the floor with our eyes bulging out like Arnie did in
Total Recall.
And lo, even the power supply managed to stay on – and they could even still watch BBC News 24.
Then, of course, we had the cliff-hanger ending, with the Doctor getting shot by a Dalek and starting his regeneration process.
This was probably the biggest coup the BBC and Russell T. Davies had managed to pull off: was the doctor actually going to regenerate, had the BBC managed to keep a really big secret without
The Sun finding out, and who was going to be the next Doctor?
The final episode –
Journey’s End – answered those questions for us. Sort of. We all know that the Doctor regenerates when it’s time for him to die. Except David Tenant isn’t quite ready to quit yet, so he simply shot his load into the palm of his own amputated hand, which just happens to have been kept handily under the TARDIS’s console for pretty much the past couple of seasons, and suddenly he managed to repair himself. And it was time to get on with a party, because his old mate Davros was back and all his pals from past and present series, plus spin-off money-makers, had turned up to help him defeat the greatest foe the human race has ever encountered: Daleks who want to destroy everything that’s ever existed so that they can be the most powerful rulers of absolutely nothing ever created.
And this is where we really did have to suspend belief because, just as all was looking lost with the Doctor and Rose locked in Davros’s dungeon and the TARDIS about to be destroyed in the centre of the Dalek Crucible, Donna Noble touched the hand under the console and triggered a regeneration process all of her own, which resulted in her suddenly becoming just as clever as the Doctor himself and another Doctor turning up in the TARDIS, stark bollock naked.
Mum’s, uncover your children’s eyes, it was tastefully done and the nakedness was just intimated, but it was all, well, a bit rubbish anyway. The second Doctor and the foretold-by-the-Ood cleverness of Donna suddenly figure out how to fix everything and head off to commit genocide on the Daleks. Once that was done, they set about sending all the stolen planets back to their rightful spots in the universe, until there was only the Earth left and, for some reason, they couldn’t send that one back, so they decided to tow it back to its spot with the TARDIS.
To create a great big virtual tow rope they had to do simply the most unbelievable thing in the whole wide world. Trust me, you really do need to suspend belief, because what they had to do was get all their friends and a great big transmitter and use all the mobile phones they could muster to call the Doctor’s mobile phone, which would then create some sort of digital tow rope that meant the TARDIS could drag Earth all the way back to its rightful spot between Mars and Venus.
Here’s where you have to suspend your belief completely. First: it seems just a tad convenient that when the Daleks pinched Earth from its friendly chat with the Moon they also managed to bring all the communication satellites with it, so that all telecommunications could still happen. Then, while the good ol’ Doc and his friends all smiled insanely for the camera as they dragged the planet home, nobody on Earth seemed to suffer anything so much as a broken tea cup. Honestly, my Dad can do more damage to his crockery towing a caravan to Skegness. And finally, once everybody was home, they all just shook hands and went off to do their own thing as if nothing any more dramatic had happened than hearing that Jeremy Clarkson has been boasting about doing 186mph in a Bugatti Veyron. Again.
The only real thing in this whole episode that didn’t defy belief was the fact that the Doctor figured out Donna Noble really isn’t supposed to be that intelligent after all, so he wiped her mind by tapping her on the temples then sent her home to her granddad, who had to promise never to ever ever ever mention to her about the Doctor because one word about him could jog a memory and kill her instantly. Which was amazing, because then the Doctor walked up to Donna and said goodbye and she didn’t keel over dead at the sight of him.
All of this suspending belief to get to the end of what is usually a very good series has been quite tiresome and I’m glad that a two year break in the making of the show is taking place. It’s to allow Tennant to take some time out to do some Shakespeare, although there will be a handful of Dr. Who specials in the meantime, but the break will also allow the rest of us to get a grip on reality, because I really think we need it.
After all, it took all of my willpower to actually not suspend belief when I heard that, after the Doctor’s mobile phone number was shown on screen during the airing of what is, after all, a science fiction programme, 2’500 people in this country who had just watched the most unbelievable thing ever to happen with a mobile telephone picked up their own phones and rang the number.
And then they rang Ofcom and complained that the Doctor didn’t actually answer their call, nor did he arrive at their house in his TARDIS to ask them to be his next companion.
-----
· Read about the complaints here:
http://www.theinquirer.net/gb/inquirer/news/2008/07/07/dr-fans-complain-ofcom